X
                        RISMedia's ACE
Search
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Search in comments
Search in excerpt
Filter by Custom Post Type
{ "homeurl": "http://rismedia.com/", "resultstype": "vertical", "resultsposition": "hover", "itemscount": 4, "imagewidth": 70, "imageheight": 70, "resultitemheight": "auto", "showauthor": 0, "showdate": 0, "showdescription": 1, "charcount": 3, "noresultstext": "No results!", "didyoumeantext": "Did you mean:", "defaultImage": "http://rismedia.com/wp-content/plugins/ajax-search-pro/img/default.jpg", "highlight": 0, "highlightwholewords": 1, "openToBlank": 0, "scrollToResults": 0, "resultareaclickable": 1, "autocomplete": { "enabled": 1, "googleOnly": 1, "lang": "en", "mobile": 1 }, "triggerontype": 1, "triggeronclick": 1, "triggeronreturn": 1, "triggerOnFacetChange": 1, "trigger": { "delay": 300, "autocomplete_delay": 310 }, "overridewpdefault": 0, "override_method": "post", "redirectonclick": 0, "redirectClickTo": "results_page", "redirect_on_enter": 0, "redirectEnterTo": "results_page", "redirect_url": "?s={phrase}", "settingsimagepos": "left", "settingsVisible": 0, "hresulthidedesc": "0", "prescontainerheight": "400px", "pshowsubtitle": "0", "pshowdesc": "1", "closeOnDocClick": 1, "iifNoImage": "description", "iiRows": 2, "iiGutter": 5, "iitemsWidth": 200, "iitemsHeight": 200, "iishowOverlay": 1, "iiblurOverlay": 1, "iihideContent": 1, "loaderLocation": "auto", "analytics": 0, "analyticsString": "", "show_more": { "url": "?s={phrase}", "action": "ajax" }, "mobile": { "trigger_on_type": 1, "trigger_on_click": 1, "hide_keyboard": 0 }, "compact": { "enabled": 1, "width": "200px", "closeOnMagnifier": 1, "closeOnDocument": 0, "position": "fixed", "overlay": 0 }, "animations": { "pc": { "settings": { "anim" : "fadedrop", "dur" : 300 }, "results" : { "anim" : "fadedrop", "dur" : 300 }, "items" : "fadeInDown" }, "mob": { "settings": { "anim" : "fadedrop", "dur" : 300 }, "results" : { "anim" : "fadedrop", "dur" : 300 }, "items" : "voidanim" } }, "autop": { "state": "disabled", "phrase": "", "count": 10 } }
Select Page

(MCT)—Not even the Olympics are a sufficient distraction from the scandal of Jonah Lehrer. He’s the 31-year-old who rose to prominence writing such bestselling books as “Proust Was a Neuroscientist” and “How We Decide,” and delivering lucrative corporate lectures to go along with them.

On Monday Lehrer admitted to fabrications and “improper combinations” of quotes in his latest book, “Imagine: How Creativity Works” — specifically, material he’d attributed to Bob Dylan but in fact simply invented. As he announced his resignation from the New Yorker (he’d been there less than two months), his publisher announced that it had removed access to the electronic version of “Imagine” and recalled all copies of the printed version.

Lehrer was already slightly tarnished. In June, he admitted to self-plagiarizing, recycling previously published work, sometimes word for word, in his blog on the New Yorker’s website. Though he avoided widespread excoriation for that, this latest revelation has the publishing world choking on its own special blend of schadenfreude and sanctimony, blaming Lehrer’s fall on the arrogance of stardom or the scrutiny afforded by the Internet.

Whenever a saga like this erupts, we journalists tend to wag our fingers the hardest. And for good reason. These cases erode the already tenuous contract between reader (or listener or viewer) and reporter. They take the axiom “don’t believe everything you read” and give the public an excuse to twist it into “don’t believe anything you read.”

What Lehrer did was plainly wrong. Still, it would be naive to think that quotes are never massaged. Though making up words and thoughts is obviously unacceptable, “cleaning up” a quote is something of a tradition.

If someone speaks in awkward stops and starts, repetitively, ungrammatically or otherwise in a way not conducive to a verbatim appearance on the page, there is no hard-and-fast rule for making those words more reader friendly. Ellipsis points and brackets? Indirect quotes? Taking out only the “ums” and “you knows”? It all requires having enough trust in ourselves that we can also ask our readers (and those we quote) to have that trust too.

That’s a lot to ask. And in this era, frankly, it may be too much.

It’s worth noting that Lehrer’s impulse to come up with tidy quotations that seamlessly fit into his theme happened in the context of a culture in which the concepts of “documenting” and “manipulating” are no longer always at odds. Indeed, they often cannot afford to be because ideas expressed in anything but the most succinct and entertaining terms run the risk of losing the ratings wars. That is, audiences are inclined to not only prefer cleaned-up quotes, they’re likely to favor a more staged version of events over the more banal, factual version.

Reality TV shows, which now often fall unapologetically under the rubric of “documentary television,” are known to be staged for greater dramatic effect. Even some of the most acclaimed traditional documentary films can push the limits. Lauren Greenfield, director of the new release “The Queen of Versailles,” admitted in a recent interview to playing around with the order of a few scenes for the sake of a narrative arc.

Once in a while, journalists get handed something that is so juicy and so neatly presented that we need only slap it on the page and we’ve got a sexy story. But real life is complicated and generally unsexy, which means that, most of the time, the sentences and paragraphs we use to describe it will be too. Jonah Lehrer was rewarded for making complicated ideas seem simple and appealing, for making people feel smarter than they are by making things like neuroscience and the works of Proust seem easier to grasp than they are.

But his downfall is not his alone. What has also collapsed is our collective tolerance for complexity, our appetite for concepts that can’t be captured in catchy book titles or appropriated for corporate mantras and self-help seminars. In the wake of all that, should we really be surprised when a writer opts for a made-up Dylan quote over the real thing?

Sadly, no. Besides, it’s always been hard to understand what Dylan was saying. It’s not for nothing that some people thought “the ants are my friends” was what was blowin’ in the wind.

©2012 Los Angeles Times
Distributed by MCT Information Services


Buying/Selling Consumer Luxury National Spotlights
Family of five with a "For Sale, Sold" real estate sign in front of the new home they recently purchased. The family is all smiles as they are excited about their new home purchase. Father, mother, and three children. The family is outdoors in the summer season.  Children are elementary-ages. Moving house, relocation concepts.
July New Home Sales Soar to Eight-Year High

A recent new home sales report for July showed that sales...

Female Realtor On Phone Outside Residential Property
Stay Safe and Earn Big with MVP

NAR PULSE—Register now for the free REALTOR® Safety Program Webinar on...

Model  house for sale and graphs. Real estate concept.
Brand Report: Home Sales Cool, Price Increases Moderate

Unlike the month’s temperatures, July home sales cooled off from June’s...

Agent Broker Coaching Lead Gen Teams
Young entrepreneurs working in their start-up office. Focus to man in blue shirt, smiling and taking with his colleague. His fellow worker holding cup of coffee. Shot with Canon EOS 5Ds 50mp. Location is released.
Carrying on the Family Legacy

In the following article, John Turpin, Broker/Owner of Turpin Real Estate,...

Cropped shot of corporate businesspeople in the boardroom
The 4 Keys to Reproducible Results

Matthew and Janice are emerging entrepreneurs who recently went into business...

496093954
How to Create an Unstoppable Business

I come from a long line of self-employed people. The Buffini...

Agent Best Practices Branding Broker Niche
Word Cloud with Lead Generation related tags
Ask the Expert: How Much Should You Spend on Lead Generation?

Today’s “Ask the Expert” column features Arthur Darmanin, Chief Executive Officer...

Cropped shot of corporate businesspeople in the boardroom
The 4 Keys to Reproducible Results

Matthew and Janice are emerging entrepreneurs who recently went into business...

Certificate on the blue table.
Making the Most of the Resort and Second-Home Property Specialist Certification

Ryan Servatius, an associate broker with Shore Sotheby’s Realty in New...

Agent Apps/Gadgets Best Practices Broker Innovation
financial stock price
5 Ways Big Data Is Changing Real Estate

Every facet of the business world has been radically changed by...

Computer keyboard with loupe concept
Maximizing Exposure with Unique, Interactive Domains

When it comes to finding your target audience, proper listing exposure...

Silhouette of business people moving and joining pieces of jigsaw puzzle on a business and stock market  blue background, with charts, diagrams, world maps and data arranged on grid and tables. World maps showing continents and countries with economy data and growth diagrams. Light glowing from the center. Copy space on bottom.
PNC Offers Online Business Insights, Webinars and Tools for Agents

Looking for the latest real estate industry information, education and networking...

Business Insights Content Generation Marketing Trends
Nizhnevartovsk, Russia - June 12, 2013: Man hand holding iPhone 5 with Instagram App. iPhone is product Apple Inc. Instagram is an online photo-sharing and social networking service.
Visual Storytelling: Tips for Mastering the Art of Instagram

Creating and implementing a consistent social media strategy is vital for...

"Paris, France - May 27, 2012: Instagram logo on Apple iPhone display"
Instagram Is Open for Business—Find Out What This Means for Real Estate

Last week, Instagram released some major updates that could create a...

instagram_update_2
Story Time: Move Over Snapchat, Instagram Wants In

Are you using Snapchat in your real estate business? Well, you should...

Buying/Selling For Your Clients Home Improvement How-To Lifestyle
A beautifully staged modern living room within a Victoria, BC condo.
5 Dirt Cheap Home-Staging Ideas

(TNS)—We all want to make our houses look like they are...

happy family jumping together on the beach
5 Reasons to Make Family Travel a Priority

(TNS)—Whether you take advantage of last-minute travel deals or organize a...

Businessman pointing to energy efficiency rating chart and house icon concept for performance, efficiency and environmental conservation
Ask the Expert: What Should Homeowners Know about Energy Efficiency?

Today’s “Ask the Expert” column features Mark Walker, Director with NRG...

manhattan
RISMedia’s CEO Exchange

RISMedia’s 2016 Real Estate CEO Exchange September 13 & 14, 2016...

Capital Building, Washington
RISMedia’s Power Broker Forum at the NAR REALTORS® Legislative Meetings & Trade Expo

RISMedia’s Power Broker Forum at the REALTORS® Legislative Meetings & Trade Expo...

PB-annual
RISMedia’s Power Broker Forum, Reception & Dinner – Annual

RISMedia Power Broker Events 2016 Orlando, Fla. Friday, November 4, 2016...