RISMedia
  • News
  • Premier
  • Reports
  • Events
  • Power Broker
  • Newsmakers
  • More
    • Publications
    • Education
No Result
View All Result
  • Agents
  • Brokers
  • Teams
  • Marketing
  • Coaching
  • Technology
  • More
    • Headliners New
    • Luxury
    • Best Practices
    • Consumer
    • National
    • Our Editors
Join Premier
Sign In
RISMedia
  • News
  • Premier
  • Reports
  • Events
  • Power Broker
  • Newsmakers
  • More
    • Publications
    • Education
No Result
View All Result
RISMedia
No Result
View All Result

COURT REPORT: Brokerages Split on Settlements; Supreme Court Decides Landmark Regulatory Case

RISMedia looks at some of the latest legal decisions that could affect the real estate sector, from the DOJ’s probe of NAR to recent brokerage settlements.

Home Agents
By Devin Meenan
July 22, 2024
Reading Time: 4 mins read
COURT REPORT: Brokerages Split on Settlements; Supreme Court Decides Landmark Regulatory Case

Editor’s note: The COURT REPORT is RISMedia’s weekly look at current and upcoming lawsuits, investigations and other legal developments around real estate.

The latest legal proceedings ranged from class-action lawsuits targeted specifically at the real estate industry to wide-ranging national decisions that will include housing in its wake.

NAR’s petition for rehearing with DOJ has been denied

Earlier in 2024, the Department of Justice (DOJ) reopened an inquiry into the National Association of REALTORS® (NAR)—the inquiry had been closed in 2020. The DOJ seems particularly concerned about NAR’s business relationship with MLSs, believing it and associated policies could be antitrust infringement. 

NAR had previously petitioned for a rehearing in the case that permitted the DOJ to reopen its investigation. On July 12, NAR’s petition was denied by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit in Washington, D.C. Thus, the investigation will continue for the time being; a previous meeting between the DOJ and NAR did not result in substantive progress toward a resolution.

An NAR spokesperson told RISMedia: “This ruling stands in opposition to years of precedent on the interpretation of government contracts and the bedrock principle that the government must honor its word. We are evaluating all remaining legal options and are committed to exploring all avenues to ensure the DOJ is held to the terms of our 2020 agreement.”

The Supreme Court overturns Chevron Deference, upending regulatory state

In 1984, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Chevron U.S.A., Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc. that federal regulators have broad authority to interpret and apply regulations as they see fit, and courts should defer to agencies’ expert opinions when deciding regulatory cases. 

Under “Chevron Deference,” courts would generally allow agencies to interpret and apply statutes based on their own expert opinions. Judges themselves would decide questions based on Congress’ intent when passing a regulation rather than a strict textual reading. (e.g., a new disease-causing chemical is discovered after the law regulating such chemicals was written. Agencies would classify it as hazardous under that law, and courts would respect that, even if that particular chemical couldn’t be specifically listed as such in the law because the lawmakers were unaware of its existence at the time.)

On June 28, the Supreme Court overturned this precedent in Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo. Chief Justice John Roberts wrote, “Chevron’s presumption is misguided because agencies have no special competence in resolving statutory ambiguities. Courts do.”

Legal experts have said the decision will be a consequential one, including in the housing market, for it opens the door to legal challenges on long standing regulations. Housing experts have been split by these potential ramifications.

More brokerages settle in seller class-action lawsuits, several others opt to continue litigation

July 15 marked a filing deadline for defendants in Gibson v. National Association of REALTORS®. Filed in Missouri, Gibson is a consolidated class-action lawsuit by homesellers who sold using an NAR-affiliated MLS. 

When that deadline came, United Real Estate and HomeSmart became the latest brokerages to settle in homeseller class-action lawsuits. United CEO Dan Duffy said in a release:

“We have always been committed to providing the best support and value for our brokers and agents. This settlement allows us to focus on empowering agents with the tools and resources they need to compete and serve their clients with excellence, without the burden of prolonged litigation.”

Under this settlement, United Real Estate will pay $3.7 million. Like most other brokerages that have settled, it will make changes to its business rules while denying any accusation of wrongdoing.

The settlement had ripple effects. Plaintiff Chris Masiello in Masiello v. Arizona Association of Realtors et al (a smaller-scale class-action lawsuit filed in Arizona) filed a motion on July 22 to stay the case as it pertains to HomeSmart, as the Masiello class of plaintiffs fall under the same class as those in the Gibson case. The stay was approved shortly after filing. 

However, other plaintiffs—The K Company, Real Estate One (REO), NextHome, William Raveis, Howard Hanna, Weichert, Crye-Leike Realty, John L. Scott, eXp Realty, Baird & Warner and Keyes Illustrated Properties—filed to continue litigating the Gibson case for the time being.

“John L. Scott Real Estate has never acted as a listing broker or buying broker in connection with a real estate transaction occurring in the State of Missouri,” wrote Lennox Scott, owner of John L. Scott Real Estate, in a filed affidavit. “In my entire tenure as an agent or officer of John L. Scott Real Estate, I have never believed that it would be possible or reasonable to be subject to jurisdiction in a Missouri court.”

Tags: Chevron DeferenceCourt Reportgibson v. narHousing PolicyKamala HarrisMLSNewsFeedNational Association of REALTORS®PremierReal Estate LawReal Estate LawsuitsSupreme Court
ShareTweetShare

Devin Meenan

Devin Meenan is an assistant editor for RISMedia, writing Premier content and assembling daily newsletters for digital publication. His writing at RISMedia typically focuses on political issues and legislation impacting the real estate industry; he is the creator of the “Legislative Round-Up” series. He holds a B.A. in English and Film from Denison University, where he was also Arts & Life editor of student-run paper The Denisonian.

Related Posts

Congress Takes Massive Step in Outlawing the Use of ‘Trigger Leads,’ Passes NAR-Supported Legislation
Industry News

Congress Takes Massive Step in Outlawing the Use of ‘Trigger Leads,’ Passes NAR-Supported Legislation

October 17, 2025
Luxury Agent Helen Hernandez Archer and The Archer Group Returns to eXp
Industry News

Luxury Agent Helen Hernandez Archer and The Archer Group Returns to eXp

October 17, 2025
Damon
Agents

Data Integration Company Repliers Appoints Rhett Damon as CEO

October 17, 2025
profit
Industry News

Nearly Half of Home Sellers See 50% Profit in Q3, Per ATTOM Data

October 17, 2025
Which Homeowners—and Homebuyers—Will Benefit From the New SALT Cap?
Industry News

Which Homeowners—and Homebuyers—Will Benefit From the New SALT Cap?

October 17, 2025
Fathom
Agents

Fathom Acquires Residential Brokerage START Real Estate

October 16, 2025
Please login to join discussion
Tip of the Day

What to Watch Out for When Editing Listing Photos

Learn the tricks of the trade to nail down many ways to photograph properties, from snapping quick pics with a smartphone to shooting on a proper camera mounted on a tripod. Read more.

Business Tip of the Day provided by

Recent Posts

  • Congress Takes Massive Step in Outlawing the Use of ‘Trigger Leads,’ Passes NAR-Supported Legislation
  • Luxury Agent Helen Hernandez Archer and The Archer Group Returns to eXp
  • Data Integration Company Repliers Appoints Rhett Damon as CEO

Categories

  • Spotlights
  • Best Practices
  • Advice
  • Marketing
  • Technology
  • Social Media

The Most Important Real Estate News & Events

Click below to receive the latest real estate news and events directly to your inbox.

Sign Up
By signing up, you agree to our TOS and Privacy Policy.

About Blog Our Products Our Team Contact Advertise/Sponsor Media Kit Email Whitelist Terms & Policies ACE Marketing Technologies LLC

© 2025 RISMedia. All Rights Reserved. Design by Real Estate Webmasters.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Premier
  • Reports
  • News
    • Agents
    • Brokers
    • Teams
    • Consumer
    • Marketing
    • Coaching
    • Technology
    • Headliners New
    • Luxury
    • Best Practices
    • National
    • Our Editors
  • Publications
    • Real Estate Magazine
    • Past Issues
    • Custom Covers
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Podcasts
    • Event Coverage
  • Education
    • Get Licensed
    • REALTOR® Courses
    • Continuing Education
    • Luxury Designation
    • Real Estate Tools
  • Newsmakers
    • 2025 Newsmakers
    • 2024 Newsmakers
    • 2023 Newsmakers
    • 2022 Newsmakers
    • 2021 Newsmakers
    • 2020 Newsmakers
    • 2019 Newsmakers
  • Power Broker
    • 2025 Power Broker
    • 2024 Power Broker
    • 2023 Power Broker
    • 2022 Power Broker
    • 2021 Power Broker
    • 2020 Power Broker
    • 2019 Power Broker
  • Join Premier
  • Sign In

© 2025 RISMedia. All Rights Reserved. Design by Real Estate Webmasters.

X